Why cant criticism be constructive, legitamate and meaningful??

[Loqtrall]

@ilikem14

@Loqtrall

Though it’s the pre-alpha build, it is representative of gameplay that EA and DICE felt was complete enough to show to millions of people publicly, at a scheduled event that they put together and invited over a dozen celebrities to.

Expecting people not to criticize some aspects just because it’s Pre-Alpha is naive thinking.

For instance - look at the Announcer’s Voice - pretty much everybody hates it. For all we know, if everyone just shut up about it because it’s the pre-alpha, they could take that as a sign that nobody hates it, and keep it in the full game.

You’re essentially saying “Stop whining now, you’ll have plenty of time to whine later” - but it doesn’t matter because the whining is going to go on from the time the gameplay is revealed, to the time the very last person stops playing Battlefield 1 years from now.

If there’s something someone doesn’t like in a game - and there’s a forum dedicated to people expressing their concerns about the game - they have ever right to whine about it, just as you have the right you’re expressing now by whining about people who whine.

Did you honestly think the announcer wasnt a place holder?

Thats it I quit

And you’re assuming it was a place-holder - that’s neither been confirmed nor denied. That’s just as ridiculous as assuming it was there for a reason and would be kept if everyone loved it.

“It’s a place-holder because it’s pre-alpha” could be an argument for a myriad of things that people don’t like about the pre-alpha shown off so far.