Just connect to the router via Wifi or Lan and you could play at the same time. Maybe you have IP conflict and both PCs take the same IP. Or your ISP is a ¯_(ツ)_/¯ and can’t hold them. But i got a 10MB connection and I’ve connected 4 PCs at the same time and I’ve played a LOL or Overwatch with friends.
It has a lot to do with ISP, public vs private IPs…etc. It’s a pain to get working if you’re not lucky enough for it to work on your setup…Router is a factor, too.
I had this problem with BF3 and BF4 when playing with 2 PCs on the same network. One PC would always get a connection error upon the other connecting.
Sounds like you have a NAT router which means you may have a heck of a time getting BF1 to work, if at all. The other games worked because the inbound port wasn’t used the same as in BF1.
Search how to use two PCs with a NAT router. There may be something that works but I suspect an updaded router will be in your future.
Sounds like a familiar problem with CS, COD or Quake Live, with those you can change the ports the game uses to connect to servers by editing the “net_port” (different port for each player) so 2 or more players on the same network can play with each other.
Eskha, do you have UPNP enabled? (in the router) If not it might help.
I have seen this problem before if I remember right.. you have to give each computer a static IP.. Then add rules for the ports (ALL OF THEM) for EG IF BF1 uses port 220 you have to set one rule for all incoming traffic (on port 220) to go to one computer (192.168.1.85) and the same rule for the the other (192.168.1.86).
Netgear R7500 Nighthawk and ASUS AC1900 are 2 routers that can handle 2 or more PC’s/consoles with no issues.But they’re a little pricey.
There’s some really cheap routers out there (under $30) that will do the job but at the cost of limited features.
This is the most likely cause. Once turned off on the router it will work normally. No need for any changes from routers default config appart from that normally.
But if you turn off the router then you will have no internet. So your on about a network switch ??? maybe you have a managed network switch? If that’s the case I would suggest replacing it with a NETGEAR GS205, which works great for small home networks.
As for UPNP is there not a option to turn it on? most just have a on/off..