now we got a weekly mission make 6 melee attack but its terrible at all
i try to stab in the guy front of me some wierd animaton played what move automaticly my screen i cant control it and the guy shot me down,
anoter if he prone and i stab it 50/50 chance to show kill animation or only deal 28-30 dmg on him.
if i stab in the back or prone enemy plz 100% 1 hit kill whit animation.
plz fix the melee attack, and dont take away the aim control me if i try stab from front.
I used to love collecting dog tags in bf3/4 but since bf1 the whole melee takedown thing is ruined and buggy as hell.
Like you I flank go for the takedown and start prodding with my knife instead of doing a takedown.
Pointless melee system and melee weapons, just need to make it simple like Bad Company 2.
It’s easy. You just got to know when to go for them. You also need to understand different weapons have different traits. It’s all about the flanks. It’s also good to have it bound to a key you can smash quick. I get a lot from smashing it after I land a bullet or 2 on someone in CQC.
Ps. Trust me on this. It’s the only part of the game I’m good at. 
2nd 
on PC for dog tags taken. The animations arouse me.
Melee seems fine to me.
https://xboxclips.com/GRAW2ROBZ/25415936-df3a-494d-812d-6875c6b98729
Lol, speaking about buggy melee. BF4 had the worst melee system I’ve ever seen. I preferred using a defibrillators to kill someone front behind because I never knew if animation will get bugged or not.
If you can’t rely on regular melee attacks, go for bayonet charge. Compared to nerfed and pathetic state in BF1, charging enemies in BFV is fun and satisfying.
I just wish you could still take dog tags, that the thing that really made knifing people fun honestly. Tangible evidence that your doing a good job at it
Don’t use knives just take a heavier melee weapon like a pickaxe or hatchet.
One shot with the revolver, one whack with the axe - done
…or find some hillcampers 
Bf4s system was fine for the most part. I think you were just bad at melee
I do not know how many times I have had to stab people 4 times before they die. It is so frustrating.