I think this would be a good way to balance it out and make the Scout class actually be useful for reconnaisance.
+1
I fully agree
Agree with this.
Yes definitly
Yes I Agree. The other spotting would be auditory and on small CD as it used to be.
Skrate up, mang.
It will make snipers play a more important part in Battlefield again.
Best suggestion so far
But BF1 does have an improvement that makes it just a bit less casual.You can only see spotted enemies that are in direct line of site,and if they go behind a building it instantly disappears
I’ll +1 this.
Then when hillhumpers say “I’m helping, I’m helping!” it would actually be true for a change.
Wow, seriously???
This really makes counterplay finally possible. So you mean, when I getting out of “Line Of Sight” then my mark disappear? Really good if so.
If that is the way it’s going to work then I’ll be more than happy to hear that
This.
Also the minimap only has circles so you don’t know which way a spotted player is looking at.
That’s what i saw from some gameplay videos but i’m not really sure yet
can they just do away with 3D spotting? I would agree to spotting only for scouts only to show up on Minimap
Sounds like a good idea.
I’ve brought up this idea like few dozen times already, and I never got such positive feedback from it. . .
ITT hill campers
Me in similar thread:
I’d be totally fine with 3d spotting being limited to scout class if it could only be done with binoculars. So you would have to equip binoculars as a gadget, switch to them in game, zoom in, then press spot.
The thing is it comes back once you get back out of cover. I think it should just disappear and not come back.
Not a competition bud, as long as it gets in the game! 
That sounds even better. But then if it would be a gadget that takes up a slot in place of another weapon then you should get more points for spotting.