To be fair, even John Wick would struggle to use the pistols we have at the moment, they’re a pile of .
Even BF1 offered us more to choose from at its release and we were allowed to customise them to some extent.
What we have now, feels like they almost forgot to add them in and literally put no thought into them.
As a 31* Bodeo user from BF1 and it being my highest kills weapon; I am incredibly unimpressed with the MkIV in BF5. Needing 3 shots to kill at a target less than 25 meters away is a slap in the face. Yes, I’m aware of the OHK headshot in close, I don’t think it actually matters that much.
I generally use the 1911 on Medic and Support, Repeiterpistole (sp?) on Medic and Recon, and that’s about it.
There was some guys analyzing the damage of the pistols (on reddit). Their conclusion was the repetierpistole or the revolver are the best damage-wise.
I think they found out that the repetierpistole was the best gun overall, it had the longest 3-hit-kill-range.
The revolver can one-shot-kill with headshots up to 7 meters though.
The reality of a Revolver round hitting you in the head within a reasonable range would pretty much turn your head into a canoe, so 7m seems a bit unfair and short don’t you think?!
I can’t control the revolver or repetierpistole for my style of play. If I ever have to use my sidearm, I mash my controller, hoping the fire rate prevails.
I once shot a guy with my primary for what I remember was 80-90 damage at about 50m. I switched to the P38, whatever the starter pistol is, and shot him again, still no kill, and finally I got a headshot on him to kill him. Let’s just say it was 80 damage, plus 2 pistol shots at 50m.
Depends on the Round… I believe the MkIV used the .455 Webley which is slightly larger than the 45 acp the 1911 uses. What is interesting, is that the 45acp the 1911 used in WWII was a faster round than the .455 Webley and have more energy to the target. the 45 acp in 230 grain FMJ would hit with about 369 ft/lbs. the .455 Webely with a 265 grain FMJ would hit with 289 ft/lb. in real life both pistols would mess up your head (the 9mm fMJ could potentially be survivable depending on location but probably will still kill you).
basically all the .45s should hit harder than the revolver other than the liberator (barrel length negates full powder burn)… but that would really mess up balance so the fact that the revolver one hit kills at all seems fair.