i vote first 
i prefered BF1 the first war is amazing, the guns, vehicles and the maps is beautifull 
and now what is your favorite?
Any battlefield other than BF1.
Im playing both. One for my ww1 craving and the other nfor my more modern combat craving..
why choose?
Too early to tell for me yet. But I’m certainly leaning towards BF1.
why?
bf4 with out a doubt…
battlefield 4 without a doubt been on alpha beta and trial with bf1 to make my mind up and i can tell you i wont be buying bf1 due to trashy hitboxes and trash tick rate and with confidence i can say the 60hz servers for bf4 are 1000x better than the 60hz bf1 servers for sure and such a shame i had high hopes for bf1 and feel let down hard
I actually had good hit detection in bf1. But the spread is so high the bullets were going all over the place missing its mark by like 3 feet. Even I was firing 2-3 shot bursts crouched. LOL. DICE really needs to halve the random spread to make the gunplay more satisfying.
BF1 for sure… Battlefield 4 was a complete mess at launch…Netcode, rubber banding, and 10 patches later its stable..but the gameplay has worn out its welcome. It feels dated
Enter BF1… I’m not experiencing netcode issues or rubber banding. I’m an infantry guy, and the maps I’ve played so far on Domination are GREAT. They each play differently and unlike previous BF games I’m never complaining at my screen “AWH, THIS MAP AGAIN!!!” because they all look beautiful and play beautifully.
Though I love BF4 I’ll have to say BF1 now, the trial has been awesome. And the new Operation mode is a blast 
BF1 any day of the week.
BF1 is lightyears ahead of BF4. 4 had the most boring maps of the series, and 1 probably has the very best. That alone puts it ahead, but the sound and effects are just so much better now that there’s no looking back for me.
Personally, I’m also sick and tired of modern rifles and Abrams tanks–we have had the same weapons and all that for like 10 years now so this change is so needed.
anything other than the ¯_(ツ)_/¯ stain that is bf4. Horrible game i tell u
BF1 all the way!
Just as @CrasyCanuck said. When I crave WW1 I’ll play BF1 (which will be a lot once it launches for me on the 18th). If I want my modern day setting where I can go in and take down helo’s with my SRAW I got BF4 (hurry up with that UI update, DICE, pls).
Waaaaay too early to tell which one is better
BF1 no question
Both at the moment. It’d be much easier to compare BF3 and BF4 as they are very close together time period wise. As for BF1, I mean were going back in time here to World War 1, so they are fairly different games.
If I feel like playing an older World War theme, BF1 it is. If I want more modern conflicts, BF4 it is.
At the moment though it will be mainly Battlefield 1.
Why not a actual straw poll?