So, yes the rate system out of ten, based on the live stream.. 10 Being absolutely, pre order and buy (Maybe even deluxe version).
So, hope to.hear your thought…
Lol
I won’t decide for sure until after I play the beta, but based on what I have seen so far of the gameplay and graphics etc I have no doubt I will be pleased with the beta. 10 for me.
10
Im not even regarding the era or any thing like that, just looking at it even in pre alpha state.
wow what a nice step up for FPS, you no when you see them games that define the next progression etc the next step up etc they raise the bar etc
Even if I hated FPS and hated WW1 and didnt want to play it, with an objective view just about the game, graphics, detail, game play, game engine, diversity, I’d still say the same, wow.
Looks great, map design seems really good, dynamic weather is gonna help to mix things up. A definite 10/10 for me.
10/10. Few minor concerns, but confident that Dice will deliver.
If it released right now I’d probably still enjoy it a lot but there’s still a bit of work to be done (as one would expect) so its 8/10 for me.
There’s still a lot more we dont know about such as the horses, the flamethrower guy, the game modes etc.
While I’m very excited for the game, the stream was probably like a 7/10, really (good, but has room for serious improvement). For one, the voice-over/announcer was too awkward and out-of-place. Secondly, too many useless celebrities that were stoned out of their minds.
Most of the celebs did pretty horrible at the game. DICE should have actually gotten more actual gamers, and StoneMountain shouldn’t have had to steal a bunch of people from Neebs’ team. The coordination/teamwork of the gameplay suffered due to such.
From the marketing standpoint, and the enjoyment of the viewer, it’s MUCH wiser and more sensible to have actual gamers to show off coordinated gameplay rather than useless celebs that just caused a bunch of confusion with their teammates.
The current female voice over is a place holder from what’s been said. Expect that to change by release (or Beta even)
The celebrities were just there for the promotion. A lot of people tuned in just to see Snoop Dogg play Battlefield (even though in the end he barely got any screen time).
Fair enough about the voice-over. I remember the “Be advised!” guy from Battlefield 3’s beta! 
Snoop Dogg went like 0-11 in one of the games and was in very last place. All he did was blaze a doobie. An actual gamer that would have made the gameplay more interesting would have been better for promotion, honestly.
i thought it looked great and seemed to play well.
i am pre ordering the deluxe so its a 10/10 from me.
the only thing that looked wrong was the bi planes hitting buildings and not getting damaged, the wings should break off. but its early days.
About 2 or 3 out of 10
WHY? because what you see is not what you’ll get (Remember the BF4 showcase etc etc etc) all the tubers etc etc etc gave it rave reviews and such then Boom game released, what did we get a buggy/lag/rubberbanding rampant mess that was worse than the Alpha and Beta and then it took nearly 2 years to fix, and now people are suckered into the new shiny BF trailer and gameplay just to get people hooked and to pre - order.
battlefront launch was fine
It was a bad game with minimal content at best and nothing on the scale of battlefield games.
but hey good on everyone who believes the hype (knock yourselves out drooling at something you may never get) ie what was in the showcase EA event to what you’ll actually get on release.
Sorry just telling it how it is and always has been (for once not going to be suckered into the trailer and gameplay hype)
Why don’t they just tell the truth and that goes for all Devs their mantra should be.
What you see is not what you’ll get.
the game ran fine, i am not talking about content.
I would rate 8/10. (not 9 just because I’m worried about the count of the weapons)
Hope DICE will see this, but I have an idea for snipers (making it short); As they would take direct hits, their reticle could become just a bit bloody. 
As they would get more and more (direct) hits they would have to clean their weapon. (mechanic: like when a driver repairs his vehicle from inside) I would certainly make this happen really slowly, so it wouldn’t become annoying, but this could potentially slow down campers, so you could “disable them” for some time when you wanted to make dangerous moves on the battlefield. 
5 out of 10 nothing really stood out n amazed me, tbh looks like a step back from BF4!
From what i’ve seen so far…
9/10
9/10, people need to stop crying about a possible bad launch, battlefront was perfect, I think DICE/EA learned from BF3 and BF4 launch.
About the game, the first true BF feeling was there, maybe because I enjoyed historic settings so much I don’t know, but the gameplay seems amazing also the graphics are over the top for a Alpha.
Swbf only had 40 players and no destruction so those things may be a factor to how well bf1 plays!
6,5/10
looked alright.
nothing ground breaking or special TBH.
will be waiting to see more footage of other maps and such.