Yes or No ? No buts , no if’s , yes or no ?
Straight up
Looks more like bf4 than hardline! Going to go with my gut and say no
I’m saying yes . I see players getting bored fast
No, It’ll last at least as long as BF4.
Really? Seeing the varity from the trailer it looks much more diverse than hardline or bf4. Never know though…
Straight up a no
The setting has more potential for gameplay I personly like.
More hardcore vs casual.
If it goes further down the path of casual I am out
I never go by the trailer . Sure every trailer to every game looks cool but its all about the game play
No it won’t fail. Next question
No it wont fail but I can see a lot of people getting bored. WW2 would have been better, or perhaps a mix of both.
No heavy tanks (wooopee) sniper weapons are pant and noob tubing simply aint going to be an option 
however, was WW1 not all about trench warfare?
No, WW1 in a modern “AAA” engine will be amazing.
If they coddle to the whiners and 12 years olds it will fail because they will just have a reskinned BF4. If they stick true with none of these stupid experimental weapons and scopes that everyone and their brother know weren’t even close to being widespread they will be fine. Iron sights and heavy, heavy water cooled MGs.
One holo or reflex sight will end the idea of this game. They will have catered to the whiners and 12 year olds.
It depends. Are they going to ruin the game by adding Star Wars: Battlefront play style or mechanics? If so, then yes.
If they keep it purely in the Battlefield spectrum then I think it will do well…just as long as the shovel whacking someone makes a satisfying noise.
I’ve bought them all, no need to stop now. Plus it looks great!
Why would you even ask this? Of course it won’t fail…
No. Hopefully without all the sight upgrades we’ll get back to the BF2 style gameplay. Which to date is still the best BF title, imo.
Considering we have only seen a 20 second trailer of a game that isn’t even fully developed yet its hard to answer. But after seeing the trailer, my gut feeling tells me that this could be one of the best games of 2016.
Nope. I can honestly say in my long history of gaming (I’m pushing 50) I have not been this excited for a game in as long as I can remember.
Don’t bank on that. You have people here digging up Reflex sights from 1900 and such. This game will not be what you nor I expect. And that is extremely sad.
I don’t believe there were reflex sights during that time period. There were however rifle scopes.
YES — but only the empty servers would be a fail. Like the other games with an empty server is fail.. I want them to add bots on empty servers so an empty server is sort of like playing the single player but on a map instead of a mission until the right amount of players arrive to start the round.